Premier League Regular Season - 29

Newcastle 2 - 1 FT Manchester United

St. James' Park

Match previews and recaps to help you decide which games are worth watching

Futmetrix Verdict
82
FT
Wed, Mar 4
Newcastle
2-1
Manchester United
⚡ Intensity 94
⚖️ Balance 56
🏆 Stakes 0
🎲 Upset 10
Ten-man Magpies stun Champions League hopefuls

Ten-Man Newcastle Stun United in St. James' Park Thriller

Highly Entertaining Futmetrix Score: 82/100. This result breathed fire into Newcastle's season while delivering a bruising reality check to Manchester United’s top-three ambitions.

The Chaos of St. James'

St. James' Park was a cauldron of noise as Newcastle hosted Manchester United in a match that defied logic. A high Intensity rating was established during a chaotic first-half stoppage time that saw the game turned on its head. It began with disaster for the hosts as J. Ramsey saw red for diving in the 46th minute, leaving his side a man down. Despite the numerical disadvantage, Anthony Gordon stepped up deep into added time to bury a clinical penalty. However, the celebrations were short-lived; Casemiro equalized just minutes later, heading home a pinpoint cross from B. Fernandes. The teams went into the tunnel level, but with the hosts facing a grueling second half with ten men.

The Tactical Grind

The second half became a masterclass in defensive resilience. Manchester United controlled possession with a 55% share, but they struggled to find the clinical edge needed to break a disciplined black-and-white wall. The Balance of the match shifted as Eddie Howe's men sat deep, relying on the tireless energy of Anthony Elanga to spark counter-attacks. Sandro Tonali was instrumental in the heart of the pitch, winning crucial duels and dictating the tempo despite the man deficit. Erik ten Hag’s side peppered the goal with 14 shots, yet they lacked the creative spark to beat an inspired home defense that refused to buckle under the pressure of the top-four contenders.

The Resolution

Just as a draw seemed inevitable, the Upset Factor reached its boiling point in the 90th minute. A brilliant delivery from K. Trippier found the substitute W. Osula, who had only been on the pitch for five minutes. Osula’s clinical finish sent the home crowd into a state of pure pandemonium, sealing a famous 2-1 victory against the odds. For Newcastle, this was a statement of pure grit that lifts them away from mid-table stagnation. Meanwhile, the Red Devils leave Tyneside reeling, their grip on a Champions League spot suddenly looking far more precarious after failing to capitalize on a massive advantage. This was a night where spirit triumphed over status.

Key Questions

How did the red card for J. Ramsey impact the match?

It forced Newcastle to defend deep for 45 minutes, but their disciplined shape ultimately frustrated a Manchester United side lacking clinical finishing.

How dramatic was the late winner by Sandro Tonali?

Actually, W. Osula scored the 90th-minute winner, though Tonali’s midfield mastery was the engine behind Newcastle's improbable victory.

How did substitute Sandro Tonali change the game?

Tonali actually started the match, providing three key passes and elite leadership to guide the ten-man Magpies to a win.

What is the Futmetrix Score?

The Futmetrix Score is our 0-100 verdict on how entertaining a match is. We look at intensity, balance, stakes, and star quality to tell you if it's worth your time.

Match Statistics

Possession
45%
55%
Newcastle 45%
Manchester United 55%
Shots
12
14
Newcastle 12
Manchester United 14
Shots on Target
5
5
Newcastle 5
Manchester United 5
Expected Goals (xG)
2.22
1.28
Newcastle 2.22
Manchester United 1.28
Passes
374
457
Newcastle 374
Manchester United 457
Pass Accuracy
77%
82%
Newcastle 77%
Manchester United 82%
Corners
2
4
Newcastle 2
Manchester United 4
Fouls
15
15
Newcastle 15
Manchester United 15
Yellow Cards
4
3
Newcastle 4
Manchester United 3
Red Cards
1
0
Newcastle 1
Manchester United 0

Match Events

26' 🟨 J. Ramsey
B. Mbeumo 🟨 37'
38' 🟨 Joelinton
L. Shaw 🟨 39'
45'+1 🟨 J. Ramsey
45'+1 🟥 J. Ramsey
45'+6 A. Gordon
Casemiro (B. Fernandes) 45'+9
HT
46' 🔄 H. Barnes J. Willock
L. Shaw M. Ugarte 🔄 61'
Casemiro D. Dalot 🔄 61'
N. Mazraoui 🟨 64'
K. Mainoo A. Diallo 🔄 76'
B. Mbeumo J. Zirkzee 🔄 77'
80' 🟨 K. Trippier
84' 🔄 A. Elanga J. Murphy
85' 🔄 A. Gordon W. Osula
N. Mazraoui T. Malacia 🔄 85'
90' W. Osula (K. Trippier)
90'+7 🔄 S. Tonali S. Botman
FT

Player Cards

Our take on every player in this match

Newcastle

Goalkeepers
Aaron Ramsdale
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
96
Total Mins
Started
Entry
Defenders
Kieran Trippier
PROVIDER
PROVIDER
1
Assists
1
Assists
1
Key Passes
7.2
Rating
Malick Thiaw
STORMTROOPER
STORMTROOPER
1
Shots
1
Shots
0
Goals
1
On Target
Dan Burn
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
96
Total Mins
Started
Entry
Lewis Hall
PROVOCATEUR
PROVOCATEUR
4
Fouls Won
4
Fouls Won
6
Duels Won
0
Pens Won
Midfielders
Jacob Ramsey
FRIENDLY FIRE
FRIENDLY FIRE
Red Card
Mistake
Red Card
Mistake
2
Fouls
5.3
Rating
Sandro Tonali
ARCHITECT
ARCHITECT
3
Key Passes
3
Key Passes
0
Assists
26%
Pass Acc
Joelinton
MAGNET
MAGNET
74
Activity
74
Activity
54
Passes
20
Duels
Forwards
Anthony Elanga
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
6
Late Mins
6
Late Mins
84
Total Mins
84
Entry
Anthony Gordon
PROVOCATEUR
PROVOCATEUR
4
Fouls Won
4
Fouls Won
6
Duels Won
1
Pens Won
Harvey Barnes
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
45
Total Mins
46
Entry
BENCH
Nick Pope
SPECTATOR
SPECTATOR
0
Saves
0
Saves
0
Conceded
0
Minutes
Sven Botman
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
1
Total Mins
Started
Entry
Alex Murphy
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
0
Total Mins
Started
Entry
Leo Shahar
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
0
Total Mins
Started
Entry
Joe Willock
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
51
Total Mins
Started
Entry
Jacob Murphy
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
12
Total Mins
Started
Entry
Yoane Wissa
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
0
Total Mins
Started
Entry
Sean Neave
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
0
Total Mins
Started
Entry
William Osula
CLUTCH HERO
CLUTCH HERO
90
Goal Time
90
Goal Time
Goal
Impact
7.6
Rating

Manchester United

Goalkeepers
Senne Lammens
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
96
Total Mins
Started
Entry
Defenders
Noussair Mazraoui
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
5
Late Mins
5
Late Mins
85
Total Mins
85
Entry
Leny Yoro
STORMTROOPER
STORMTROOPER
1
Shots
1
Shots
0
Goals
1
On Target
Harry Maguire
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
96
Total Mins
Started
Entry
Luke Shaw
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
61
Total Mins
61
Entry
Midfielders
Casemiro
SNIPER
SNIPER
100%
Conversion
100%
Conversion
1
Goals
1
Shots
Kobbie Mainoo
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
14
Late Mins
14
Late Mins
76
Total Mins
76
Entry
Bryan Mbeumo
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
13
Late Mins
13
Late Mins
77
Total Mins
77
Entry
Bruno Fernandes
FRIENDLY FIRE
FRIENDLY FIRE
Pen Given
Mistake
Pen Given
Mistake
1
Fouls
7.5
Rating
Matheus Cunha
PROVOCATEUR
PROVOCATEUR
5
Fouls Won
5
Fouls Won
17
Duels Won
0
Pens Won
Forwards
Benjamin Šeško
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
96
Total Mins
Started
Entry
BENCH
Altay Bayındır
SPECTATOR
SPECTATOR
0
Saves
0
Saves
0
Conceded
0
Minutes
Tyrell Malacia
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
11
Total Mins
Started
Entry
Ayden Heaven
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
0
Total Mins
Started
Entry
Godwill Kukonki
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
0
Total Mins
Started
Entry
Diogo Dalot
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
35
Total Mins
Started
Entry
Manuel Ugarte
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
35
Total Mins
Started
Entry
Tyler Fletcher
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
0
Total Mins
Started
Entry
Amad Diallo
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
20
Total Mins
Started
Entry
Joshua Zirkzee
LATE SHIFT
LATE SHIFT
15
Late Mins
15
Late Mins
19
Total Mins
Started
Entry

Head to Head

Date Home Score Away Competition Venue
26/12/2025 Manchester United 1 - 0 Newcastle Premier League Old Trafford
13/04/2025 Newcastle 4 - 1 Manchester United Premier League St. James' Park
30/12/2024 Manchester United 0 - 2 Newcastle Premier League Old Trafford
15/05/2024 Manchester United 3 - 2 Newcastle Premier League Old Trafford
02/12/2023 Newcastle 1 - 0 Manchester United Premier League St. James' Park
01/11/2023 Manchester United 0 - 3 Newcastle League Cup Old Trafford
02/04/2023 Newcastle 2 - 0 Manchester United Premier League St. James' Park
26/02/2023 Manchester United 2 - 0 Newcastle League Cup Wembley Stadium
16/10/2022 Manchester United 0 - 0 Newcastle Premier League Old Trafford
27/12/2021 Newcastle 1 - 1 Manchester United Premier League St. James' Park
26/12/2025
Premier League Old Trafford
13/04/2025
Premier League St. James' Park
30/12/2024
Premier League Old Trafford
15/05/2024
Premier League Old Trafford
02/12/2023
Premier League St. James' Park
01/11/2023
League Cup Old Trafford
02/04/2023
Premier League St. James' Park
26/02/2023
League Cup Wembley Stadium
16/10/2022
Premier League Old Trafford
27/12/2021
Premier League St. James' Park
Newcastle Win
Manchester United Win
Draw